The Real Problem

The Belmont Club has a couple of posts up that are critical of Obama. The first examines his “I am so tried” excuse for miss handling the the visit Gordon Brown. The second post examines the signs that his honeymoon may be coming to an end.

Both of these posts are worthwhile if your only object in life is to repay Obama with the same kind of treatment that was given to Bush. But as far as addressing the real issues of the day, these posts miss the mark by a wide margin. The real problem is articulated by Obama himself in a recent interview with The New York Times….

As he pressed forward with ambitious plans at home to rewrite the tax code, expand health care coverage and curb climate change, Mr. Obama dismissed criticism from conservatives that he was driving the country toward socialism. After the interview, which took place as the president was flying home from Ohio, he called reporters from the Oval Office to assert that his actions have been “entirely consistent with free-market principles” and to point out that large-scale government intervention in the markets and expansion of social welfare programs began under President George W. Bush.

No fair minded person could deny that what Obama is doing is largely the continuation of the polices that Bush pursued. To the extent that markets seem to be punishing Obama’s every missteps harder it is because they thought that Bush’s plans were only there to keep everything from collapsing until Obama arrived with a real plan. Now that everyone can see that Obama’s plan is just an expanded version of Bush’s plan, it is harder for the markets to convince themselves that some magic fairy is going to arrive and save us.

But this realization is not likely to do Republicans (or the nation) much good until a credible alternative to Obama/Bush’s economic rescue plan is put forth. Right now, few people really believe that Republicans would behave all that differently then Obama if they still held the presidency. Nothing that either McCain or Bush has said or done offers any kind of real contrast to how Obama is behaving. And in my experiences this is widely realized among the blue collar white males who form a key part of the traditional Republican governing coalition. This post from Rod Dreher talking about a recent conversation he had with a blue collar conservative reflects a lot of conversations that I have heard. Toward the end of the post Rod Dreher says…..

A couple of things were clear to me. One, this working-class conservative voter had bitter contempt for the Republican Party in particular, and the political and financial elites in general. He believes, quite correctly in my view, that they’re looking out only for themselves, that they will avoid a just reckoning for the disaster they’ve caused. And two, there’s no telling what kind of backlash is brewing once people lose faith in the institutions of politics and finance. This is just one repairman in Texas on one day in the spring of 2009. But I am sure he’s not alone.

The key point that a lot of conservatives seem to be avoiding in their critiques of Obama is that the only alternative to what he is trying to do is the complete destruction of the existing system. In fact, many of them go so far as to argue that Obama is trying to remake the existing system and that is why is so dangerous. But the truth of the matter is that failure of the existing system is what is going to happen and that is going to change the American economic/poltical system in ways that are far more radical then anything Obama could dream of accomplishing. Acting as if Obama’s program is an attempt to bring about radical change instead of an attempt to prevent radical change is not really productive.

In the end, I think that the failure of Bush/Obama approach is a forgone conclusion. In fact, I think that by trying to head off the collapse Bush/Obama plan is making things worse. When you factor in the strain on government finances that will be brought about by retirement of the baby boomers and I just don’t see how the current system can keep functioning.

I am not alone in thinking this, of course. In fact, on both the right and left of the political system, you can find people who salivate over the prospect of a collapse because they believe that the forces that would be unleashed could be stage-managed to produce the society that they desire.

But if we are honest with ourselves, both liberals and conservatives would have to admit that there is no guarantee that the system that would arise out of such a collapse would be more to our liking then the current system. The problem with collapses is that they are inherently unpredictable and uncontrollable. A collapse could lead to huge increases in government power. It could lead to a sharp rise in racism and the oppression of minorities as a matter of government policy. It could lead to a rise in prominence of religious groups that are not even on the radar right now (economic problems have historically been good for the creation of new cults). It could lead to war and strife.

That is why everyone wants to attach huge importance Obama’s every little misstep and mistake. People would like to fool themselves into thinking that a trip into the unknown could be postponed if only our political leaders would do things right. Obama himself has this belief. That is why he is working himself into such a state that his aids worry he is not getting enough sleep. He thinks that if he just tries hard enough he might be able to make a difference.

But the truth is that the plane we are on is going to go down over unknown terrain. You can argue about which way would be the best way to crash land if you want. Or can try to fool yourself into thinking you can keep the plane in the air with positive thinking. But in the end, you can’t escape the fact that we are going to crash.

You are being asked to sign a blank check

From the New York Times…..

Turning to domestic affairs, Mr. Obama indicated that the end was not in sight when it came to the economic crisis and suggested that he expected it could take another $750 billion to address the problem of weak and failing financial institutions beyond the $700 billion already approved. Maintaining support for the additional costs of bailouts is quite likely to be among Mr. Obama’s biggest challenges, given the anger that many Americans feel toward Wall Street executives who they believe are being unduly rewarded with bailout money.

Is this on top of the extra 500 billion that the FDIC wants? Its not clear to me how much more money Obama plans on throwing at this problem in total. The real answer seems to be as much as it takes. But what if it is beyond the resources that are available to save everything and everyone? How long before people start thinking about triage?

Loan originators taking advantage of the FHA

From the Washington Post…..

This decade’s housing boom rendered the agency irrelevant. Americans raced to aggressive lenders, seduced by easy credit and loans with no upfront costs. But the subprime mortgage market has crashed and borrowers are flocking back to the FHA, which has become the only option for those who lack hefty down payments or stellar credit. The agency’s historic role in backing mortgages is more crucial now than at any time since its founding.

With the surge in new loans, however, comes a new threat. Many borrowers are defaulting as quickly as they take out the loans. In the past year alone, the number of borrowers who failed to make more than a single payment before defaulting on FHA-backed mortgages has nearly tripled, far outpacing the agency’s overall growth in new loans, according to a Washington Post analysis of federal data.

From the end of the article…..

“Even if the market eventually gets these guys, they shouldn’t have to wait for the market to do it,” said Brian Chappelle, a former FHA official who is now a banking industry consultant. “The most frequent question I get asked by the groups I talk to is: ‘Is FHA going to implode?’ . . . They haven’t seen HUD do anything significant in the past two years to tighten up its lending.”

The entire article ought to put a lie to idea that more regulation would prevent another housing mess like the one we are in. Two years on in hosing crisis that was caused by bad underwriting and a government agency is still being taken to the cleaners by loan originators. You would have thought that if government regulators where any good they would have caught a clue by now.

Things You Don't Want To Know

From the Wall Street Journal…..

The legislation, introduced late Thursday by Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd, would temporarily allow the FDIC to borrow $500 billion to replenish the fund it uses to guarantee bank deposits, if the Federal Reserve and Treasury Department concur. Those funds would be distinct from the contentious $700 billion financial-sector bailout, which lawmakers are loathe to expand.

It would also be distinct from the stimulus plan. But who really cares? What difference one way or another will another half trillion dollars make? It is only equal to the cost of another war in Iraq.

From The San Fransisco Chronicle…….

In a 2006 ruling, Henderson said the $1.1 billion medical care system was causing the unnecessary death of one inmate per week. He said the state was incapable of repairing the system and appointed a manager to run it under his supervision.

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger called for a return to state control last month. He also has appealed Henderson’s order that the state pay the first $250 million of the manager’s $8 billion plan to rebuild prison hospitals.

The courts can appoint managers who are superior to the elected authorities? I can see giving people standing to sue or forcing pay outs to those deemed to have died “unnecessarily.” But it seems to me that under this reasoning the Supreme Court could decided that the Federal government was not allowing people to exercise all their constitutional rights and so they were going to appoint a new president.

From Life on the Line…..

I will make it semi-official on the recorded line. I tell my dispatcher that I will be more than happy to try to get airborne (that is what I get paid for…), but in my opinion, we should think about canceling the flight. He puts me on hold for a few minutes…

“We want you to try.”

I would really hate to be on a plane were the pilot said that “we should think about canceling” and was told “we want you to try.” But I imagine that it happens a lot.

Anything for a cigarette

From Strategy Page…..

Since navigation was often uncertain when Zeppelins were flying above clouds, some were equipped with an observation basket that could be lowered through the cloud layers. In that way one or two men in the basket would have a good view of the earth’s surface. From this position, they could keep the ship informed by telephone of the landmarks below, helping it navigate to and from its target.

Of course this was particularly hazardous, as the men were without parachutes in a flimsy basket dangling at the end of a 750 meter tether, in freezing cold. Yet there never seems to have been a shortage of volunteers for this duty. In part this was due to the very high morale of the airshipmen. But volunteers also gained a privilege denied to everyone else on the ship; the little basket dangling at the end of nearly a half-mile of cable was the only place on the airship where a man was allowed to have a cigarette.

This ought to be illegal

From Bloomberg…..

The misleading numbers posted by retirement fund administrators help mask this reality: Public pensions in the U.S. had total liabilities of $2.9 trillion as of Dec. 16, according to the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College. Their total assets are about 30 percent less than that, at $2 trillion.

With stock market losses this year, public pensions in the U.S. are now underfunded by more than $1 trillion.

That lack of funds explains why dozens of retirement plans in the U.S. have issued more than $50 billion in pension obligation bonds during the past 25 years — more than half of them since 1997 — public records show.

The quick fix for pension funds becomes a future albatross for taxpayers.

In the CTA deal, the fund borrowed $1.9 billion by promising to pay bondholders a 6.8 percent return. The proceeds of the bond sale, held in a money market fund, earned 2 percent — 70 percent less than what the fund was paying for the loan.

The public gets nothing from pension bonds — other than a chance to at least temporarily avoid paying for higher pension fund contributions. Pension bonds portend the possibility of steep tax increases.

Read the whole article for all the disgusting details. For example, by law most states have to guarantee pay back of those pension bonds.

Even Toyota…..

From the Times….

The loan-financing arm of Toyota, Japan’s biggest industrial giant, is understood to have approached a state-backed fund for as much as $2 billion in emergency loans.

A request for Government funding from the Japanese giant is expected to trigger a deluge of other demands for capital by other of the country’s struggling industrial companies.

When the article says $2 billion dollars it means dollars not the equivalent value of yen. What this means is that Japan is going to have to sell some T-bonds if it is going to honor this request.

Given the scale of the T-bond market, this is small potatoes. Still, it does demonstrate the mechanism by which T-bond yields could spike even if Japan or China do not decided to deliberately dump dollars as a matter of policy.

Always remember that it could be worse

From Fox News…

The rock, estimated to be no more than 200 feet wide, zoomed past our planet at an altitude of 40,000 miles at 1:44 p.m. universal time — or 8:44 EST.

Dubbed 2009 DD45, it was discovered only on Friday by Australian astronomers.

Forty thousand miles may sound like a lot, but it’s only about one-seventh of the way to the moon, and less than twice as far out as many telecommunications satellites.

Had 2009 DD45 hit the Earth, it would have exploded on or near the surface with the force of a large nuclear blast — not very reassuring when you consider humanity had only about three days’ notice.

If that had hit in the wrong place, it could have made the falling stock market seem like a minor problem.